“ELOQUENT AND TOUCHING. THIS IS DONALD MARGULIES’ MOST PERSONALLY HEARTFELT PLAY. Smoothly directed by Daniel Sullivan and acted with fine-grained conviction by a cast led by Adam Arkin, who is excellent throughout, ‘BROOKLYN BOY’ REMINDS US HOW REWARDING MARGULIES CAN BE.” - Ben Brantley, The New York Times

“TRULY ONE OF THE BEST PLAYS I HAVE SEEN! YOU REALLY MUST GO!”– David Richardson, WOR Radio

“UPROARIOUSLY FUNNY!”– Howard Kissel, NY Daily News

“ONE OF THE MOST PURELY ENJOYABLE PLAYS TO COME ALONG ON BROADWAY IN QUITE A WHILE.ADAM ARKIN is SPLENDID, and POLLY DRAPER, ARI GRAYNOR, ARYE GROSS, KEVIN ISOLA, MIMI LIEBER and ALLAN MILLER are all TERRIFIC!”– Clive Barnes,The New York Post

“GRADE:A.RESONATES WITH UNPARALLELED GRACE.”– Melissa Rose Bernardo, Entertainment eekly

“IT’S HARD TO IMAGINE A BETTER PRODUCTION THAN THIS ONE.”-Michael Sommers, The Star Ledger

“THERE’S A NEW PLAY ON BROADWAY THAT WILL RESTORE YOUR FAITH IN THEATER!” – Jacques le Sourd, The Journal News